Photo by Sonika Agarwal on Unsplash
In Prothero’s seminal work God Is Not One, he presents a four-part framework to understanding religions: identifying the central problem each religion addresses, the solution it offers, the techniques it employs to move from problem to solution, and the exemplars who embody this path.
To gain a more nuanced perspective, we will then juxtapose Prothero’s doctrinal, structural analysis with Diana Eck’s insights from her essay on darsan.
Prothero’s four-part approach, applied to Hinduism, progresses as follows:
1. Central Problem of Hinduism:
Prothero notes the central problem in Hinduism as the cycle of samsara — an endless cycle of birth, death, and rebirth — coupled with dukkha, or suffering. This perpetual cycle is driven by karma (actions) and avidya (ignorance), trapping individuals in a state of perpetual dissatisfaction and hindering their realization of the ultimate reality.
TL;DR: samsara (cycle of life and death) drives suffering (dukkha).
2. Solution Posited by Hinduism:
The solution Hinduism offers is moksha, or liberation from samsara. Moksha is achieved through the realization of one’s true self (atman) and its unity with the universal soul (Brahman). This transcendence involves overcoming ignorance and desires, thereby attaining eternal peace and unity with the divine.
TL;DR: moksha, or liberation from samsara, is the solution.
3. Techniques Offered by Hinduism:
Hinduism provides various paths and practices to attain moksha, tailored to individual temperaments and inclinations:
• Bhakti Yoga (Path of Devotion): Emphasizes loving devotion to a personal deity (e.g., Vishnu, Shiva).
• Jnana Yoga (Path of Knowledge): Focuses on intellectual inquiry and the discernment of the real from the unreal.
• Karma Yoga (Path of Action): Involves selfless service and performing one’s duties without attachment to outcomes.
• Raja Yoga (Path of Meditation): Centers on meditation and mental discipline to control the mind and senses.
4. Exemplars of Hinduism:
Deities as Exemplars: Gods like Shiva, Krishna, Vishnu, and Rama embody principles of dharma and devotion.Saints and Sages: figures like Adi Shankaracharya and Ramanuja provide philosophical frameworks and spiritual guidance in human form.Historical Figures: reforms like Mahatma Gandhi demonstrated the application of Hindu principles in social and political contexts.
Prothero’s Doctrinal Approach versus Eck’s Experiential Focus
Diana Eck’s essay on darsan delves into the sensory and experiential dimensions of Hindu worship, as we covered in my article on the subject here. Darsan is a profound, reciprocal interaction between devotee and the divine.
Approaching Hinduism through Eck’s writings and perspective highlights aspects that Prothero’s approach underemphasizes:
Sensory Engagement: sensory engagement is central to the Hindu devotional experience, making worship an immediate and tangible encounter, as opposed to a purely philosophical or theoretical practice.Reciprocal Relationship: devotees not only behold the deity but also offer their reverence and devotion. This mutual interaction of sorts creates a sense of connection and emotional fulfillment.Community and Identity: Darsan practices often occur within communal settings, thus serving to reinforce social cohesion, social bonds, and collective identity & consciousness among devotees.
Thus, Eck’s contributions to Prothero’s analysis may be summarized as follows:
Importance of embodied experiences.Emotional and psychological aspects of Hinduism.Visual & artistic significance.
So, combining Prothero’s and Eck’s exploration of Hinduism merges a doctrinal four-part framework with an experiential, visual, and lived domain.
Hope that helps you out! Feel free to leave any questions or thoughts in the comments. Also, check out my full Religion 101 article list (useful for studying, or just learning!) here.
References
• Prothero, S. (2010). God Is Not One: The Eight Rival Religions That Run the World — and Why Their Differences Matter. HarperOne.
• Eck, D. (1997). Darsan: Seeing the Divine Image in India. Princeton University Press.